How to Get Your List Engaged: Email Storytelling the Right Way - Pin Revolution Labs

How to Get Your List Engaged: Email Storytelling the Right Way

Don’t Know What to Send to Your Email List? Here’s an easy answer.

Tell them a story.

Not a “Ladies and gentlemen, do I have a terrific deal for you today” story. That’s the kind of stuff people get bombarded with a thousand times a day.

I’m talking about a real story like you would tell to a friend face to face.

Why would you do that? Because most subscribers are numb to the countless emails that crash their inbox. Promises of massive weight loss, wild claims of systems that will make you money while you sleep, you name it.
Subscribers have seen it all and they’ve heard it all. Most of them glaze over the emails in a zombie-like state before sending the emails to the trash bin. When you’re surrounded by a sea of marketers who are sending promotional emails non-stop, how do you stand above the waves? How do you become a beacon of light in this stormy sea of spam?

The answer – email storytelling.

How to Do Email Storytelling the Right Way

You could call it a tool or technique… or even a strategy. Terms don’t matter. What matters is that it works like a charm.

Many self-help books love to reprise stories about how, Colonel Sanders, was rejected 1,009 times before his recipe was accepted and he made KFC a household name. Or there is the story about Abraham Lincoln who overcame repeated failures and finally became President.

We’ve all heard these stories over and over… and yet they’re repeated over and over. There’s a reason for this. People love hearing stories. The same kid who asked his parents to read him the same story book over and over is now an adult who enjoys reading stories that uplift his spirits.

Email storytelling is a method of weaving stories, personal experiences, etc. into your emails to hook your readers and keep them interested in what you have to say.

Doing it effectively is an art, and if you can manage it, you’ll have loyal readers who eagerly open your emails first before any other email. You’ll now be that lighthouse amidst the sea of emails that crash against the cliffs of the trash and spam inboxes.

The good news is we all have the power of storytelling inside of us whether we realize it or not. Everyday, when we engage with our friends and family, we are telling stories.

When you go to write your next email to your list, don’t put on your “Internet Marketer” hat. When you do, you write emails that no one wants to read. Leave on the hat you wear when you are telling your best friend a funny or good story about your day.

Write your email like you are talking to one person and you will connect with your audience better.

Why You Should Write Like a Storyteller and Not an Internet Marketer

In case you’re not convinced, here are some of the benefits of being an email storyteller.

1. Interesting and engaging

By using email storytelling, your emails will be different from most emails sent by others which are salesy and hyped up. Readers don’t enjoy opening emails only to get pitched to repeatedly. Sure, you should pitch a product every now and then because you’re running a business. However, the stories in your emails will take the edge off the sales pitch.

2. More likely to be shared

When your emails are interesting and fun, chances are high that people will want to share your emails with their friends and on social media too. Once you reach this level, people will look forward to your emails just to see what you have to say next.

3. Sparks conversation

You’ll also find that your subscribers reply to your emails when they’re personable and entertaining. This is engagement and it’s good for two reasons. The first reason is that it improves your deliverability.

Email service providers (ESP) will look upon your emails more favorably because of the engagement between the sender and receiver. So, there’s a much lower chance of you ending up in the spam box due to the ESPs filters.
The second reason is… (see the next point)

4. Builds loyalty and trust

When your emails have insights, opinions and personal stories, your readers will subconsciously form a bond with you. They’ll feel like they know you well. They’ll trust you and be much more loyal subscribers. Your unsubscribe rates will drop, and your email open rates will rise. They’ll trust your product recommendations and buy from you.

5. Gives hope

The stories in your emails can and will inspire your readers. If you have an email list of people interested in weight loss, sharing success stories can give hope to those who are struggling.

If you are a successful online marketer, sharing your mistakes and triumphs with your readers will motivate them to overcome failure and strive for success. Your readers may forget what you wrote in a week or two, but they’ll not forget how you made them feel.

6. Makes the abstract simple

Sometimes certain concepts may be difficult to explain. By using stories, you can simplify things and get your points across succinctly and effectively. Notice how most of the Aesop’s fables and other childhood stories that you used to hear when you were young always had a moral at the end? It’s the same principle.

7. Stand above the noise

The last benefit is the most important benefit of the lot. Being a skillful email storyteller will put you head and shoulders above the competition. Once you find your voice, you’ll be inimitable… and even if your competition tries to copy you, they’ll never do it as well as you.


It will take time for you to cultivate the skills necessary to write to your subscribers in a way that inspires, motivates and entertains. This will be time that’s well-spent and will reap rewards for you over and over in the long run, by increasing your subscriber retention rates and boosting your sales exponentially over time.

Still in the planning phases of building your list? Stop planning and start doing with the super easy 1-2 punch of Mailerlite plus Both are free to start. Mailerlite is an easy to use, free autoresponder and Sumo will give you the pop ups and boxes to capture emails.  Check it out now!

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below

Leave a Reply:

Get the "No Idea Instant Business Starter" Guide Free.